top of page
Search

A Cautionary Tale - The Estate Agency Agreement

Writer: Matthew Gardiner Legge
Matthew Gardiner Legge
22 hours ago
4 min read

The estate agent's "Sole Agency Agreement" is the contract you sign when instructing an estate agent to sell your home. These contracts vary in length and are mostly, in my opinion, irrelevant fluff. 


Full transparency: I've never even read mine all the way through; nine pages of legalese is not my idea of a good read. It's not that I'm irresponsible, it's just that it's a standard industry document and in 35 years of using them, I've never needed to get to grips with the finer points contained within. 


The contract needs only to establish a few basics; the address, name of the legal owner, the initial asking price, the fee charged (and when it is due for payment) and importantly, the "exclusivity" period. And it is this last point that is where you - the client/seller - can come unstuck. 


The point of the exclusivity period is to give the agent a fair amount of time to sell the house, After all, they’re operating on a no sale/no fee basis and will be spending a fair sum of money on marketing. The question is, however, what is a fair amount of time? Eight weeks used to be the industry norm but this was back in the days when a town would have only two or three competing companies and things were relatively 'friendly'. 


However, fast forward quite a few years and the industry is very much changed. House prices have risen dramatically leading to much higher fees which in turn have attracted many more players all competing for ever smaller pieces of the property pie.


Of course something had to give and back in the day in London - where else? - a certain agent (think Green cars and offices like bars) came up with a genius, some would say ‘dastardly’, solution to the problem of securing the largest market share. The idea is simple enough and it has changed the way estate agency was done and continues to be done across the land and yes, even in Oxford where I am based!

 

It's this: price high, charge high, then tie 'em in! I’ll explain. 


Price high... this is where you, dear seller, become hooked. The shiny suited, fast talking and credible listing agent - let's call him Steve - will flatter you senseless, tell you how amazing your house is and will then smash you in the face with an eye watering lottery sized figure of how much your house is "worth" - probably 20% more than the next highest agent quoted you. So now Steve very much has your attention!

 

Charge High...Your next enquiry will be the fees, to which Steve will flash his very wide grin and calmly explain that his fee is 2.5%; almost certainly a whole percentage point more than his nearest competitor. BUT Steve will explain that if he's going to get you such a high price for your house then he's absolutely worth the 2.5%.... at which point you'll probably agree. And before you know it, you've signed the agency agreement. 


Off Steve goes, happy in that he's a step closer to hitting his monthly listing target whilst you, buoyed up with your new-found ‘worth’, are now looking at houses in a much higher price bracket than you were earlier, happy in the knowledge that you're going to get a LOT more for your house than you thought you were a couple of hours earlier. 


Tie 'em in: the ‘clincher’. The weeks go by and nothing happens. Viewers came and went in the beginning but now no one comes. You speak to the agent (not that nice Steve by the way, he’s just ‘the lister guy’) who commiserates and spins a narrative about the market changing and perhaps you might consider a small reduction? After more weeks go by, anxiety and stress levels rising, you start exploring how you can extricate yourself away from Steve and his cowboys and go with the local independent agent who you originally wanted to go with. Except… you can’t. You’re tied in for 26 whole weeks - that's six months in old money!

 

And there you are - trapped! 


Over the next few months your asking price will fall bit by painful bit, until it reaches a level that the market will consider. Eventually you sell it but you're angry. You'll never use THEM again. But they don't care. They spend fortunes on marketing - that is money spent attracting new clients, not on marketing your house properly. It's a model that is very lucrative and makes shareholders very happy. 


But it's a model that only serves the company. It’s a model that literally wrecks lives, wrecks dreams, destroys plans and above all leaves the industry wide open to well-deserved criticism. 


So there you have it... check that exclusivity period and anything over eight weeks, start asking questions. It shouldn't take more than eight weeks to find a buyer.

 

Oh, my exclusivity period? I don't have one. 



To follow Michael Gardiner Legge and peruse the properties he currently has on the market: 


 
 
 

Comments


Federation of Small Businesses
Cambridge Chamber of Commerce
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • Blue Sky
  • LinkedIn

Cambridge Estate Agent buying selling

The-Property-Ombudsman-TPO - logo.jpg
bottom of page